Case Study: Navigating the Path to Private Equity – A Journey of Persistence, Relationships, and Strategic Engagement

Case Study: Navigating the Path to Private Equity - A Journey of Persistence, Relationships, and Strategic Engagement

Written By: Gerald O’Dwyer III 

The PE Guru — Blackmore Partners, Inc | June 21, 2024

Private equity (PE) offers a unique opportunity for executives to leverage their skills and experience to generate significant financial returns; however, breaking into the PE industry requires more than just an impressive resume. It demands persistence, strategic relationship-building, and a thorough understanding of the market and deal-making processes. This case study explores the journey of an executive, John Doe, as he transitions into the private equity landscape, applying key principles and strategies discussed by Gerald O’Dwyer during the Blackmore Group Meetup.


John Doe, an experienced executive in the technology sector, has decided to transition into private equity. He has spent over 20 years in corporate roles, demonstrating strong leadership and strategic planning capabilities. However, John realizes that the world of private equity is vastly different from his corporate experience and requires a different approach.

The Current M&A Landscape: A Market Context

Before diving into John’s journey, it’s essential to understand the current M&A landscape, characterized by a significant “dam” in the middle market. This dam, akin to the Hoover Dam, symbolizes the convergence of various factors:

– Abundant Capital: Private equity firms are flush with $12 trillion in buyout funds.
– Low Supply of Targets: Despite the capital, there is a shortage of investment opportunities due to high interest rates, low debt multiples, and tight lending standards.
– Extended Hold Periods: Many PE firms are holding onto portfolio companies longer than usual, with an average hold period of 5.8 years, the longest in 15 years.

This market context presents both challenges and opportunities for business owners and executives like John.

The Journey Begins:
1. Understanding the Importance of Relationships

John starts by recognizing that relationships are the cornerstone of private equity. He dedicates significant time to building and nurturing connections with business owners, PE firms, and industry professionals. He attends networking events, industry conferences, and workshops to meet potential partners and mentors.

Key Actions:

– Attends ACG and BlackmoreConnects conferences.

– Joins professional groups and networks focused on private equity.
– Engages with industry leaders on platforms like LinkedIn.


John’s network has begun to grow, providing him with valuable insights into the PE industry and potential deal opportunities.

2. Building and Managing a Funnel

John learns the importance of maintaining a robust funnel of potential deals and contacts. He utilizes databases such as Pitchbook and Cyndx to identify companies that fit his investment criteria. John methodically reaches out to these companies and begins building relationships with their owners.

Key Actions:
– Creates a list of 200+ potential targets using industry databases.
– Sends personalized emails and follows up with phone calls to engage owners.
– Develops a tracking system to manage his outreach and follow-up activities. Outcome:

John establishes a steady pipeline of potential deals and gains insights into market trends and owner expectations.

3. Developing a Clear Deal Thesis

To stand out to PE firms, John understands that he needs a clear and compelling deal thesis. He focuses on his expertise in the technology sector, particularly in SaaS and data storage. John articulates his thesis, emphasizing growth potential, market trends, and his strategic vision for the companies he targets.

Key Actions:
– Researches market trends and identifies high-growth opportunities in the technology sector.
– Develops a detailed deal thesis highlighting specific investment criteria and growth strategies.
– Prepares a presentation and supporting materials to share with potential PE partners. Outcome:

John’s well-defined deal thesis attracts interest from several PE firms, who appreciate his strategic approach and industry knowledge.

4. Engaging in Action Learning

John moves beyond theoretical knowledge by actively participating in the deal-making process. He reaches out to business owners, initiates discussions about potential acquisitions, and navigates the complexities of deal structuring. John learns from each interaction, refining his approach and expanding his knowledge.

Key Actions:
– Initiates conversations with business owners about potential acquisitions.
– Attends workshops and seminars to improve his deal-making skills.
– Seeks feedback from PE professionals and mentors to refine his strategies.

John gains practical experience in deal-making, building his confidence and competence in the private equity space.

5. Navigating Economic and Market Trends

John stays informed about the broader economic environment and market trends. He understands that the current economic landscape is rapidly consolidating, which presents both challenges and opportunities. John uses this knowledge to identify sectors poised for growth and potential acquisition targets.

Key Actions:
– Monitors economic indicators and industry reports to stay informed about market trends.
– Identifies sectors with high consolidation activity and potential growth opportunities.
– Adjusts his deal thesis and strategy based on evolving market conditions.

John’s awareness of market trends allows him to identify and pursue high-potential opportunities, positioning himself as a knowledgeable and proactive executive.

6. Leveraging Conferences and Networking

John actively participates in industry conferences and networking events to expand his reach and build credibility. He uses these opportunities to pitch his deal thesis, gather feedback, and forge new connections. John’s presence at these events signals his commitment to the PE industry and his willingness to engage with peers and potential partners.

Key Actions:
– Regularly attends ACG, BlackmoreConnects, and other relevant conferences.
– Participates in panel discussions and workshops to showcase his expertise.
– Follows up with contacts made at these events to nurture relationships.

John’s active engagement at conferences and networking events enhances his visibility and credibility, leading to valuable introductions and potential deals.

7. Adapting to Challenges and Persisting

Throughout his journey, John faces numerous challenges, including deals falling through and owners getting cold feet. He remains persistent, learning from each setback and continuously refining his approach. John’s resilience and adaptability become key factors in his success.

Key Actions:
– Maintains a positive and persistent attitude despite setbacks.
– Continuously refine his deal thesis and outreach strategy based on feedback and experience.
– Keeps a long-term perspective, understanding that success in PE requires patience and perseverance.

John’s persistence pays off as he successfully navigates challenges, builds a strong pipeline of potential deals, and earns the respect of his peers in the PE industry.

The Urgency for Business Owners: The Time is Now

Given the current market conditions, there is an urgent need for business owners to consider selling their companies. The backlog of portfolio companies held by PE firms creates a unique window of opportunity:

– High Demand, Low Supply: With PE firms sitting on $1.2 trillion in buyout funds and a shortage of investment targets, now is an opportune time for business owners to attract significant interest and potentially achieve premium valuations.
– Prepared PE Firms: PE firms have been optimizing their portfolio companies, making them lean and ready for market. Competing against these well-packaged businesses will become increasingly difficult once the dam breaks.
– Temporary Market Conditions: The current market, characterized by low supply and high demand, is not expected to last. Once the Federal Reserve begins to cut interest rates or PE firms start selling off their portfolio companies, the market dynamics will shift, potentially lowering valuations.

Key Considerations for Business Owners:

– Current Market Conditions: Understand the current economic landscape, characterized by high cash reserves in PE and a low supply of acquisition targets.
– Timing: Consider selling now before the backlog of PE-owned companies floods the market, driving valuations down.
– Preparation: Enhance business operations, reduce costs, and improve cash flow to make the company more attractive to buyers.
– Engagement: Actively engage with potential buyers, leveraging relationships and networks to maximize visibility and interest.


John Doe’s journey into private equity illustrates the critical importance of relationships, strategic engagement, and persistence. By actively participating in the process, continuously building and managing his funnel, and staying informed about market trends, John successfully transitioned into the private equity space. His story serves as a valuable roadmap for other executives seeking to enter the PE industry, highlighting the need for a clear deal thesis, proactive networking, and an unwavering commitment to learning and growth.

For business owners considering a sale, the current market presents a unique opportunity to achieve premium valuations. By understanding the market dynamics, preparing their businesses, and engaging with potential buyers, owners can capitalize on the high demand for acquisition targets and navigate the complexities of the private equity landscape effectively. The time to act is now before the dam breaks and the market becomes flooded with competition.

BMP Logo connected

Email Us